One of the fun things about a vertical tasting is following how a wine evolved over the years. Of course, the question comes right up…how well have the older wines held up over the years?
Fortunately, the recent Merlot vintage vertical at The Lenz Winery proved once again the magnificent staying power of their wines, and spoke strongly to the staying power of Long Island wines. (Side note: we also had the privilege of a vertical tasting at Bedell Cellars of Musée release from 2007 to 2023, and of checking out a 1995 Cabernet Sauvignon from Peconic Bay Vineyards…all of which were sensational!)
Back to Lenz… Six vintages of
Merlot were offered in side-by-side tastings, starting with a comparison of Old Vines 2000 and Old Vines 2001 releases. Both wines held up, with some gorgeous fruit showing in the 2000, and more complexity and tannin in the 2001.These were followed by a head-to-head of Old Vines 2002 and Old Vines 2007. Again, the 2002 held its own, showing off the fruit and tannins that make it a classic. But, the 2007 remains in a class by itself! This was a banner year on Long Island, and the wine showed that. It remains a classic!
Finally, the match-up of the day: 1993 Old Vines Merlot and 2013 Old Vines Merlot. Note that 2013 was another great year on Long Island, and this vintage held true (and remains a favorite when it can be gotten). The showstopper, however, was the 1993. A 33-year-old wine that held up beautifully with a fantastic fruit profile. As noted by Lenz, there were 50 cases of this wine held back at the time so as not to sell out, and it is the vintage that started their wine library. What a treasure!

Throughout the tasting, Vineyard Manager Emeritus (as in recently retired) Sam McCullough, Winemaker Thomas Spotteck, and Lenz owner Peter Carroll gave a running commentary on the vineyard practices, winemaking processes and profiles, and history of the wines and winery. .Notes provided described each of the wines vintages and growing seasons (for example, regarding the 2007 magnum, “Hot and dry, among the best vintages ever for Long Island; Wine Spectator rated the season A” and 2013, “A cold, wet spring gave way to summer heat and a long dry autumn’ hailed as one of Long Island’s greatest.”
One final note. The comments made indicated that the winery believes their Old Vines reds peak at 10-20 years, and that although some of these wines were past that timing, they have “traded fresh fruit for layered complexity.” All, however, held up…and all were delicious examples of the ageability and longevity of Long Island Wines

